Sign in Join

Live chat for Free Pascal, Lazarus, Delphi and every Pascal programmer.

Mailing lists / fpc-pascal / 2013-08

has anyone successfully written an app for iOS using Free Pascal and got it approved by Apple Appstore?

9 messages · 5 people · –

Reply by email Subscribe to this list Your subscription

Read-only archive. Use j and k to move between messages.

Dennis Poon

Just want to make sure this path is plausible before I invest more time in it.

Thanks a lot.

Dennis

Michael Schnell
to Dennis Poon

AFAIK, the current Delphi XE can do "native code" apps for iOS (while the next release is supposed to be able to do apps for Android, as well),

I don't see why other native code apps should be banned.

-Michael

Dmitry Boyarintsev
to Michael Schnell

Here's the one, I've been involved with:
https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/icarus-sky/id450199377?mt=8 And there're others by Sergio Flores.

I'm sure there're a lot of other people out there, subscribed to MacPascal mailing list.

thanks,
Dmitry

Michael Schnell wrote 10 lines
AFAIK, the current Delphi XE can do "native code" apps for iOS (while the next release is supposed to be able to do apps for Android, as well), I don't see why other native code apps should be banned. -Michael ______________________________**_________________ fpc-pascal maillist - http://lists.freepascal.org/**mailman/listinfo/fpc-pascal<http://lists.freepascal.org/mailman/listinfo/fpc-pascal>
Jonas Maebe
to Dennis Poon: Just want to make sure this path is plausible before I invest more time in it. Thanks a…
Dennis Poon wrote
Just want to make sure this path is plausible before I invest more time in it.

Yes, several people/companies have done so. Note that since a couple of weeks, you have to use FPC 2.7.1 r25325 or later because Apple now requires that applications are linked as PIE (position-independent executables), which requires the program to be compiled with PIC (position-independent code) and earlier FPC versions did not support that for ARM/Darwin.

Jonas

Dennis Poon
to Michael Schnell: AFAIK, the current Delphi XE can do "native code" apps for iOS (while the next release is…

I would assumed so because of the existence of Firemonkey for Delphi and Xamarin for C#.
I asked this questions because I wrote a FREE (without advertisement) app with Free Pascal.
The app was about Acupuncture (Chinese medicine) and was in Chinese interface only and I submitted to the Apple App Store and got rejected.

The rejection was was
- Did not integrate with iOS features.

I was afraid that the scanned the code and discovered that it was written in Free Pascal and rejected the app, so I asked the question on this e-list.

I also asked Apple to elaborate on the rejection reasons.

Today, I got their reply:
" Please provide a demo video that presents sufficient function. Also, if the app uses web browse feature, it should be rated at 17+."

Frankly, I was unhappy and I replied:

"It is a FREE App without advertisement or anything. I don't get any reward from this app. I am mere contributing my time and effort and bore the Developer License fee of USD100 and yet it seems like I am put in court and required to produce evidence to prove that my volunteer app is good enough for your app Store. No wonder there are many categories in which Android has Free (or paid) apps but IOS does not. "

Dennis

Michael Schnell wrote 17 lines
AFAIK, the current Delphi XE can do "native code" apps for iOS (while the next release is supposed to be able to do apps for Android, as well), I don't see why other native code apps should be banned. -Michael _______________________________________________ fpc-pascal maillist - http://lists.freepascal.org/mailman/listinfo/fpc-pascal ----- No virus found in this message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 2013.0.3392 / Virus Database: 3211/6618 - Release Date: 08/28/13
Michael Schnell
to Dennis Poon
Dennis Poon wrote
No wonder there are many categories in which Android has Free (or paid) apps but IOS does not. "

AFAIK, Apple keeps a decent share of the price of any APP sold in the shop.

So it's no wonder they are not at all interested in free Apps.

-Michael

Reimar Grabowski
to Dennis Poon: I would assumed so because of the existence of Firemonkey for Delphi and Xamarin for C#.…
Show quoted text 8 lines
Frankly, I was unhappy and I replied: "It is a FREE App without advertisement or anything. I don't get any reward from this app. I am mere contributing my time and effort and bore the Developer License fee of USD100 and yet it seems like I am put in court and required to produce evidence to prove that my volunteer app is good enough for your app Store. No wonder there are many categories in which Android has Free (or paid) apps but IOS does not. "

Well done, this will show 'em. Now they have no choice but to approve it. ^^

R.

Dennis Poon
to Reimar Grabowski

Frankly, I don't like Apple. They have become arrogant and stubborn like Microsoft and old Sony and (the old IBM).
Remember Sony used to have this special type of SD card (Called Memory stick ) which are so different from other SD, MMC and they forced you to buy them (at much higher priced than SD,MMC) if you buy their electronics equipment (which only supports MemorySticks). They wanted to use their market power to force you to buy inferior stuff from them at premium price. It is exactly what Apple is doing now with its special lightning wire, iTunes (no SD allowed), awkward Objective C, X-Code, No flash etc. I sincerely hope they will suffer what Sony had with this same strategy.

In HK where I live, Iphone market share is disappearing rapidly. It's considered as old/boring by many and new smartphone users tend to choose Android (mostly Samsung, some Sony) instead of iphone as their first smartphone.

Reimar Grabowski wrote 28 lines
On Fri, 30 Aug 2013 19:23:18 +0800 Dennis Poon wrote: > Frankly, I was unhappy and I replied: > > "It is a FREE App without advertisement or anything. I don't get any > reward from this app. I am mere contributing my time and effort and bore > the Developer License fee of USD100 and yet it seems like I am put in > court and required to produce evidence to prove that my volunteer app is > good enough for your app Store. No wonder there are many categories in > which Android has Free (or paid) apps but IOS does not. " > Well done, this will show 'em. Now they have no choice but to approve it. ^^ R. _______________________________________________ fpc-pascal maillist - http://lists.freepascal.org/mailman/listinfo/fpc-pascal ----- No virus found in this message. Checked by AVG - www.avg.com Version: 2013.0.3392 / Virus Database: 3211/6622 - Release Date: 08/30/13
Jonas Maebe
to Dennis Poon
Dennis Poon wrote
Frankly, I don't like Apple. They have become arrogant and stubborn like Microsoft and old Sony and (the old IBM).

[snip]

Please take that kind of remarks/discussion to the fpc-other list. Thanks.

Jonas
FPC mailing lists admin