Hi,

In Lazarus 1.6 when I used code creation for procedures and events they will be made in private part of class and I had an option in Codetool named "Insert new event methods to section" but now in Lazarus trunk I cant find that and methods will made in public part.

What is wrong?

Regards,
Ara

http://wiki.freepascal.org/index.php?title=Lazarus_1.8.0_release_notes

Ondrej

Thanks Ondrej but Ctrl+Shift+X will show the message and I set it on private but problem is how can I set Ctrl+Shift+c default? Also If I want to it adds method after class name not in private section, what should I do?

Regards,
Ara

Aradeonas wrote

Thanks Ondrej but Ctrl+Shift+X will show the message and I set it on private but problem is how can I set Ctrl+Shift+c default?

You cannot. +C is always without dialog (predefined hard-coded settings), whereas +X is always with dialog.

Also If I want to it adds method after class name not in private section, what should I do?

This section is "published".

Ondrej

Oh no :(

I want my old behavior back, its a pain to see a dialog every time. it at least can use last chosen value with +X dialog.

Regards,
Ara

Aradeonas wrote

I want my old behavior back, its a pain to see a dialog every time.

Well not a pain for me. But you can raise a discussion about the default section for methods for +C. I always use +X for methods; the same if I want to declare an object variable. Maybe it can be changed to private.

it at least can use last chosen value with +X dialog.

This is a no-go for me.

Ondrej

Cause we had an option before, can we have it back for Ctrl+C ? just like 1.6 and no hard coded option so anyone can choose what he like?

Regards,
Ara

Aradeonas wrote

Cause we had an option before, can we have it back for Ctrl+C ? just like 1.6 and no hard coded option so anyone can choose what he like?

Well I don't know if we should make an option for every tiny feature that can be easily compensated with another existing feature. What is so painful on Ctrl+Shift+X and Enter? Do you create so many methods in one particular section?

Ondrej

Yes, and it isnt tiny and also programmers like me are lazy and a click or a enter more very time is a pain.
I didnt want option for every detail just font like messages ;) Also we had it before :D

Regards,
Ara

Where does it mention the change from default section to public section?

Mattias

Obviously nowhere. At least I cannot find that information there.

Ondrej

I dont know who changed it but here is a screen shot from 1.6

Regards,
Ara

Aradeonas wrote

I dont know who changed it but here is a screen shot from 1.6

I implemented the option in 1.5 trunk and I extended it in 1.7. During this extension I decided to delete the option because now there are much more options and it doesn't make sense for me to have duplicate functionality (+C with IDE various IDE options and +X with dialog). I decided to keep it simple.

But if you get support from other devs and/or users, you can revert the option part of the 1.7 change and bring it back. In that case send a patch through mantis. But please first try to get the green light.

Ondrej

Thanks Ondrej for your works.

You talk about various IDE options but as I searched I cant find any options to make this message off and also from my view it makes no sense forcing anybody to a shortcut do just one thing and make all the stuff in Public.
But as you are the maintainer and no one attracted in this topic for know, its your decision and yours is no so it is as is but Im grateful for your works as always.

Regards,
Ara

I personally prefer to use private as default.
I will add the option.

Mattias

Mattias Gaertner wrote

I personally prefer to use private as default. I will add the option.

Good. I add most methods to the private section as well. It looks like more people do: http://mantis.freepascal.org/view.php?id=13994 :)

Ondrej

I personally prefer to use private as default. I will add the option.

Me too, at least an option for an useful shortcut. Happy to hear that.

Regards,
Ara

> I personally prefer to use private as default. I will add the option. Me too, at least an option for an useful shortcut. Happy to hear that.

I added it.

Mattias

Thanks!

Regards,
Ara