Sign in Join

Live chat for Free Pascal, Lazarus, Delphi and every Pascal programmer.

Mailing lists / lazarus / 2000-03

Kylix article on slashdot

6 messages · 6 people ·

Reply by email Subscribe to this list Your subscription

Read-only archive. Use j and k to move between messages.

Thierry Coq
to Michael A. Hess: It is interesting but you really need to read between the lines. This is the first…

Hello,

I'm mostly following your work, which I find quite impressive.

Inprise is, from what I have learned, is committed to providing kylix to Linux developers. Inprise will provide betas quite soon, as they say to us, anyway.

Furthermore, Inprise has had a portable pascal compiler for quite some time (I've heard about it two years ago, for the first time).

The main issue is, as you well know, the portability of the VCL. I understand most of the standard VCL and database will be here. Interfaces also will be available, even if COM will not. I also understand the VCL will be available for both KDE and GNOME, although I don't know when both will be available.

One of my major concerns is the RTTI capability : I really use it very often, and it may not be complete (due in particular to Unix object files limited capabilities).

I don't think kylix will be as extensive as Delphi, yet.

The planned fusion between Inprise and Corel should increase the commitment to kylix, I have been told.

Thierry Coq

Reply by email

Michael A. Hess
to Cliff Baeseman: There si a article that was just posted on slashdot about Kylix. The article has a link…
Cliff Baeseman wrote
There si a article that was just posted on slashdot about Kylix. The article has a link to the article on borlands site about the internals of kylix.

It is interesting but you really need to read between the lines. This is the first paragraph and the last sentence tells a tale.

"This is the first in a series of Borland community articles intended to brief you, the Delphi and C++Builder developer, on Kylix technical bits that you need to be aware of to prepare yourself and your code for possible porting or migration to the Linux universe. This is a briefing of directions, issues, and solutions currently under evaluation, not a technical specification cast in stone."

This was a report of items "...currently under evaluation,..". Exactly how far away are they from even having a compiler available for Linux?

The next sentence that really gets me is:

"I'm not going to talk about VCL, or the IDE, or anything else. You'll just have to keep an eye on the Borland community site headlines to catch articles on those topics later on."

The VCL and IDE are what Delphi and C++ Builder are all about. This almost sounds like hype to keep everyone interested but really says that they are far far far from releasing anything.

==== Programming my first best destiny! ==== Michael A. Hess Miracle Concepts, Inc. http://www.miraclec.com

Reply by email

Cliff Baeseman

There si a article that was just posted on slashdot about Kylix. The article has a link to the article on borlands site about the internals of kylix.

Cliff

Reply by email

Unknown author
to Michael A. Hess: It is interesting but you really need to read between the lines. This is the first…
Michael A. Hess wrote 30 lines
Cliff Baeseman wrote: > > There si a article that was just posted on slashdot about Kylix. The > article has a link to the article on borlands site about the internals > of kylix. It is interesting but you really need to read between the lines. This is the first paragraph and the last sentence tells a tale. "This is the first in a series of Borland community articles intended to brief you, the Delphi and C++Builder developer, on Kylix technical bits that you need to be aware of to prepare yourself and your code for possible porting or migration to the Linux universe. This is a briefing of directions, issues, and solutions currently under evaluation, not a technical specification cast in stone." This was a report of items "...currently under evaluation,..". Exactly how far away are they from even having a compiler available for Linux? The next sentence that really gets me is: "I'm not going to talk about VCL, or the IDE, or anything else. You'll just have to keep an eye on the Borland community site headlines to catch articles on those topics later on." The VCL and IDE are what Delphi and C++ Builder are all about. This almost sounds like hype to keep everyone interested but really says that they are far far far from releasing anything.

Not so, they organize(d) a meeting for Component developers. I don't think they would do that unless they have something to say/show.

The manager of the Delphi team (Mr. Nadler) told me that they would be happy to have a working compiler and RTL for the first release; while I think such a statement is more intended as a brake on the enthousiasm of the marketing department, I think there is an element of truth in it anyway.

The VCL is very windows oriented, no matter what everyone says. Quickreport depends on it; most of the database stuff depends on the BDE, which is also very windows oriented (it is said to contain still old 16 bit code, but I don't know if that is true). I don't even mention COM and OLE automation, which is exclusive Windows territory.

I don't know about the IDE itself, but its need for the windows registry is also obvious, the debugger support is entirely based on the Windows debug API.. What more do you need ?

Taking out DB support, COM&OLE and Quickreport, you loose a lot ! On the other hand, Midas is quite platform independent, and you can get a long way with that...

I would be very pleased to see Kylix sport a modest number of working components (Standard, DB and Internet). That should definitely be within the grasp of the Delphi team.
After all, a team that puts together Delphi, can't be bad :-)

One day we should be able to say the same about Lazarus :-)

Michael.

Reply by email