Sign in Join

Live chat for Free Pascal, Lazarus, Delphi and every Pascal programmer.

Mailing lists / lazarus / 1999-09

Why the FLC/Lazarus/KCL development should be speeded

11 messages · 7 people ·

Reply by email Subscribe to this list Your subscription

Read-only archive. Use j and k to move between messages.

Peter Vreman
to Michael Van Canneyt: Yes, but even if they can do it, they will just run on a Corel-adapted version of linux -…
Show quoted text 20 lines
> Of course, you can discuss what a "full featured" > > Quote: > "Publicly Inprise is committed to bringing Kylix to > market by early next year at the latest. Whenever it's > done, Kylix will represent the first full-featured, > Windows-style RAD environment for Linux. While Kylix > ultimately will work with all Linuxes, Inprise will work > first with its partners ..." > > Look at the new release time !!!!! Yes, but even if they can do it, they will just run on a Corel-adapted version of linux - if I understand it right. I very much doubt that everyone wishes to buy this version; if it is more Windows-like, what is the purpose of having linux at all? If you want to implement a more windows like environment, why not just take windows ? and furthermore, If you do that you WILL introduce all of the windows bugs and quircks and even add some more.

I hope to have FPC soon in the debian distribution. And let's see if corel will take FPC, because corel is based on debian.

Peter

Reply by email

Michael Van Canneyt
to Florian Klaempfl: http://www.zdnet.com/sr/stories/news/0,4538,2343151,00.html Of course, you can discuss…
Florian Klaempfl wrote 13 lines
http://www.zdnet.com/sr/stories/news/0,4538,2343151,00.html Of course, you can discuss what a "full featured" Quote: "Publicly Inprise is committed to bringing Kylix to market by early next year at the latest. Whenever it's done, Kylix will represent the first full-featured, Windows-style RAD environment for Linux. While Kylix ultimately will work with all Linuxes, Inprise will work first with its partners ..." Look at the new release time !!!!!

Yes, but even if they can do it, they will just run on a Corel-adapted version of linux - if I understand it right. I very much doubt that everyone wishes to buy this version; if it is more Windows-like, what is the purpose of having linux at all? If you want to implement a more windows like environment, why not just take windows ? and furthermore, If you do that you WILL introduce all of the windows bugs and quircks and even add some more.

They can only do what they promise by taking wine and it's lib to provide the win32 API, and linking it in in every app. I doubt anyone will like that. What kind of application are you writing if you need 6 Meg of libs to run it ? This isn't VB you know !

Maybe I'm being too religious about it, but I definitely don't like the way it sounds.

I think the marketing guys are - as usual - missing the point and screwing things up. We should send them all on a spaceship on a collision-course with the sun, ( (c) Douglas Adams ) Same goes for million-dollar CEOs - it's they that sent Borland plummeting down in the first place, though Borland seems to get out of it now (hopefully).

Michael.

Reply by email

Florian Klaempfl

http://www.zdnet.com/sr/stories/news/0,4538,2343151,00.html

Of course, you can discuss what a "full featured"

Quote:
"Publicly Inprise is committed to bringing Kylix to market by early next year at the latest. Whenever it's done, Kylix will represent the first full-featured, Windows-style RAD environment for Linux. While Kylix ultimately will work with all Linuxes, Inprise will work first with its partners ..."

Look at the new release time !!!!!

Reply by email

Michael Van Canneyt
to Sebastian Günther: just a quick note: you know that Corel supports the Wine project...? I guess they do this…
Show quoted text 10 lines
Michael Van Canneyt wrote: > > Look at the new release time !!!!! > > Yes, but even if they can do it, they will just run on a > Corel-adapted version of linux - if I understand it right. just a quick note: you know that Corel supports the Wine project...? I guess they do this because they want to use the Wine library for the Linux version of their Office Suite.

Probably, yes, as it makes everything easier.
Whether it makes things better is debatable.

So it is really quite possible that Borland will use Wine too, as somebody already noted here...

I know the answer to that one; but it is under the NDA.

If they do it:
1) For the IDE: You'll see it by running ldd on the executable.
2) For the VCL: I doubt anyone will use it. I don't see the use of having windows run on top of Linux; you miss the point of having Linux.

Michael.

Reply by email

Baeseman, Cliff

yes I do not see them using WINE either. That would be like shooting yourself in the foot.

Cliff

Earlier message 36 lines
-----Original Message----- From: Shane Miller Sent: Thursday, September 30, 1999 12:56 PM To: Subject: Re: [lazarus] Why the FLC/Lazarus/KCL development should be speeded Borland will not use WINE. >>> Sebastian G�nther 09/30/99 11:37AM >>> Michael Van Canneyt wrote: > > Look at the new release time !!!!! > > Yes, but even if they can do it, they will just run on a > Corel-adapted version of linux - if I understand it right. just a quick note: you know that Corel supports the Wine project...? I guess they do this because they want to use the Wine library for the Linux version of their Office Suite. So it is really quite possible that Borland will use Wine too, as somebody already noted here... - Sebastian _________________________________________________________________ To unsubscribe: mail with "unsubscribe" as the Subject archives at http://www.miraclec.com/list_archives/lazarus _________________________________________________________________ To unsubscribe: mail with "unsubscribe" as the Subject archives at http://www.miraclec.com/list_archives/lazarus

Reply by email

Sebastian Günther
to Michael Van Canneyt: Yes, but even if they can do it, they will just run on a Corel-adapted version of linux -…
Michael Van Canneyt wrote
> Look at the new release time !!!!! Yes, but even if they can do it, they will just run on a Corel-adapted version of linux - if I understand it right.

just a quick note: you know that Corel supports the Wine project...? I guess they do this because they want to use the Wine library for the Linux version of their Office Suite. So it is really quite possible that Borland will use Wine too, as somebody already noted here...

- Sebastian

Reply by email

Samuel Liddicott
to Michael Van Canneyt: Probably, yes, as it makes everything easier. Whether it makes things better is debatable.
Show quoted text 11 lines
-----Original Message----- From: Behalf Of Michael Van Canneyt Sent: Friday, October 01, 1999 11:36 AM To: Subject: Re: [lazarus] Why the FLC/Lazarus/KCL development should be speeded 2) For the VCL: I doubt anyone will use it. I don't see the use of having windows run on top of Linux; you miss the point of having Linux.

Wine is not windows, it is just an api; IMHO wine is fine for the GDI support; and certainly a quick way to get it.

Sam

Reply by email

Sebastian Günther
to Michael Van Canneyt: Probably, yes, as it makes everything easier. Whether it makes things better is debatable.
Michael Van Canneyt wrote
Probably, yes, as it makes everything easier. Whether it makes things better is debatable.

I don't know, I guess that the speed will be horribly. (especially loading speeds. Just take StarOffice with its OS abstraction layers...)

1) For the IDE: You'll see it by running ldd on the executable.

of course

2) For the VCL: I doubt anyone will use it. I don't see the use of having windows run on top of Linux; you miss the point of having Linux.

Yes and no, it could work as a temporary solution until the native libraries are ready.
We will see; on the other hand I don't think this would influence any FreePascal related project (Lazarus and KCL) at all...

- Sebastian

Reply by email

Michael Van Canneyt
to Sebastian Günther
Show quoted text 7 lines
Michael Van Canneyt wrote: > Probably, yes, as it makes everything easier. > Whether it makes things better is debatable. I don't know, I guess that the speed will be horribly. (especially loading speeds. Just take StarOffice with its OS abstraction layers...)

Yes, and for this reason the win32 abstraction layer (wine) slows things down... Add to that the VCL layer and hop; one mouseclick must go through 2 extra layers.

Show quoted text 12 lines
> 1) For the IDE: You'll see it by running ldd on the executable. of course > 2) For the VCL: I doubt anyone will use it. I don't see the use > of having windows run on top of Linux; you miss the point of > having Linux. Yes and no, it could work as a temporary solution until the native libraries are ready.

Then you should better wait till you have the native version. try and do things right from the first time, is my experience...

We will see; on the other hand I don't think this would influence any FreePascal related project (Lazarus and KCL) at all...

That is true, we shouldn't look at what they do, just try and get it working.

Michael.

Reply by email

Samuel Liddicott
to Michael Van Canneyt
Show quoted text 12 lines
-----Original Message----- From: Behalf Of Michael Van Canneyt Sent: Friday, October 01, 1999 02:43 PM To: Subject: Re: [lazarus] Why the FLC/Lazarus/KCL development should be speeded Yes, and for this reason the win32 abstraction layer (wine) slows things down... Add to that the VCL layer and hop; one mouseclick must go through 2 extra layers.

How many times do you click a mouse in a second? I really don't think this can be what slows it down.

Sam

Reply by email